December, from Cortona
Cortona
The olives at La Casa Cappellina have been picked and pressed, the last of the summer's visitors went home weeks ago, and the towns around Cortona are starting to string up their lights. Anyone who has worked on a stone farmhouse knows what a Tuscan December feels like indoors, which may explain why the whole region moves out into its piazzas with something hot in its hand.
We are in the business of old buildings, so we have a weakness for seeing them used. A Christmas market on Arezzo's sloping Piazza Grande, or a truffle fair around a castle in the Crete Senesi, does what these places were built to do, which is to bring people in from the country to buy, sell and argue.
These are the markets and food fairs we would drive to this year, with the dates checked for 2026. Some are worth a weekend and one or two are worth an hour of your time, and we have said which.
The markets near Cortona
Arezzo, 14 November to 27 December. Piazza Grande is one of the great squares of Tuscany, with Vasari's loggia along the top and the apse of the Pieve at one corner, and for six weeks it is given over to the largest Tyrolean Christmas village in Italy. Stallholders come down from the Tyrol, Germany and Austria with their wooden huts, and in past years the food has run to pretzels, raclette, polenta and roast pork knuckle. It is a slightly absurd sight, an Alpine village under a Renaissance loggia, and we like it very much. Entry is free and the town is about 40 minutes from Cortona. If you can, come on the first weekend of December, when the Fiera Antiquaria brings the antique dealers into the streets around the square.
Montepulciano, 21 November to 6 January. The town bills this as the biggest Christmas market in central Italy, with around 70 huts running through Piazza Grande and along Via San Donato. Entry is free and the stalls open from 10.30 to 19.30, but until 19 December it runs on selected days only, mostly weekends, so look at the calendar before you set off. Families will want the Castello di Babbo Natale in the Fortezza, which is ticketed. Without children we would leave the castle to those who need it and find a glass of Vino Nobile somewhere out of the wind.
Cortona, December to Epiphany. Our own town works on a smaller scale. Last year the programme ran from 6 December to 6 January, with light projected on to the palazzi in Piazza della Repubblica, a different market in the old town each weekend and a living nativity at Creti on Christmas Eve. The little markets at Pierle, below the ruined fortress, are the ones we would seek out. This year's programme will appear on cortonanatale.it.
Siena and Florence
Siena, 4 to 8 December. The Mercato nel Campo is the one we would cross the province for. Now in its nineteenth edition, it recalls the market that once filled Piazza del Campo, and the stalls are given over to local producers, short supply chains and craftsmen. This year it runs for five days rather than three, from 11am to 8pm on Friday 4 and Monday 7 December, and from 8am to 8pm on Saturday 5, Sunday 6 and Tuesday 8, the Immacolata holiday. We would pick the Friday or the Monday, when the crowds should be thinner, and expect to leave with more panforte than is sensible.
Florence, 14 November to 20 December. More than fifty wooden huts go up in front of Santa Croce, open every day from 10am to 10pm, with traders from across Europe. There is very little that is Florentine about it, and the food leans firmly towards Germany. Give it an hour and a mug of something hot, then walk round to Brunelleschi's Pazzi Chapel, which is what we would really come for. If you would like the city's Christmas trees as well, they are due to be lit on 8 December.
White truffles
Alba has the reputation, but Tuscany has its own white truffles and two fairs we would choose for a November weekend. Time is short for the first of them. A truffle loses its scent within days, so buy on the last day of a trip and eat it the moment you get home.
San Giovanni d'Asso, 14 and 15 November. This is the second and final weekend of the fortieth fair, first held in 1985, in a small village in the comune of Montalcino on the bare clay hills of the Crete Senesi. Truffles are sold at the market and there are tastings around the village. The castle has a truffle museum in its cellars, and the drive there from Cortona, through the Crete in low November light, would justify the outing by itself.
San Miniato, 14 and 15, 21 and 22, 28 and 29 November. The fifty-fifth national truffle fair takes over several squares in this hill town between Florence and Pisa, with truffle hunters, producers and restaurateurs all in one place. It is about two hours from Cortona, so we would treat it as a night away rather than a lunch. Three weekends gives you some room for manoeuvre.
New oil and a village market
San Quirico d'Orcia, 4 to 8 December. The Festa dell'Olio has filled the streets of this Val d'Orcia town since 1993, and if we could only go to one thing on this list it would be this. New oil is bright green and catches at the back of the throat, the peppery bite Italians call pizzica, and it is at its most vivid in these first weeks. Having just had our own pressed at La Casa Cappellina, we hold firm views on the subject. Before the festa itself the town runs dinners with producers on 14 and 28 November and guided e-bike rides out to the farms on 15 and 29 November, all booked through the tourist office on 0577 899728.
Radicondoli, 28 and 29 November. The seventh Christmas Market brings makers, cooks and musicians into the streets of a small village west of Siena. It is well off most people's route, which is much of its appeal. Entry to the village has been free in past years, with food and drink paid for in tokens you buy when you get there.
How we would plan it
Aim for the first weekend of December, because so much of this falls together. From a base in or near Cortona, you could spend Friday 4 December at the Mercato nel Campo in Siena while it is quiet, Saturday in Arezzo among the Tyrolean huts and the antique dealers, and Sunday at the Festa dell'Olio in San Quirico d'Orcia, with lunch in the Val d'Orcia on the way home. Montepulciano's market is open that Saturday and Sunday, and the town sits on the road between Cortona and San Quirico.
Three practical points. Tuesday 8 December is a public holiday, and many Italians turn it into a long weekend, so book lunch early. These towns are built on hills and paved in stone that is slippery when wet, and the wind on Montepulciano's upper streets in December is not to be underestimated, so bring proper shoes and a real coat. Programmes also shift in the final weeks before an event, so look at the organiser's page before a long drive.
If a winter weekend here leaves you lingering at estate agents' windows, we find and restore homes across Tuscany and Umbria, and Charles Collett would be glad to talk it through.